Colorado Social Security Law Rotating Header Image

How NOT to treat someone with deafness-severe hearing loss


I recently read this story from Dr. Mark Mostert about a major airline’s inability to deal appropriately with a person with severe hearing loss.  If the Fail Blog had a corporate failure section, this would be on it.

…my wife, Deborah, has a severe hearing impairment – both ears. Deborah wears state-of-the-art hearing aids that are only somewhat helpful.

Last week my wife turned up at the United counter in Norfolk, Virginia, to check in for her flight.

United Airlines employee: Says here you have a disability. Do you need assistance?

Deb: Yes, I’m deaf.

Puzzled silence.

United Airlines employee (somewhat sullenly): Do you need assistance?

Deb: Yes, I have a severe hearing impairment.

United Airlines employee (now a little irritated): Do you need assistance?

Deb (sighing): Yes, it’s very difficult for me to hear anything. . .

United Airlines employee (obviously ready to move on): Do you need a wheelchair?

I find this exchange interesting because it does not appear to start with malice on the part of the UA employee. I can only imagine that the UA employee could not conceive that a person who was conversing with him and responding to his questions, could label themselves as “deaf.”

Is this ignorance?  Yes. But, not malice. The cure for ignorance is more information, which Deborah provides:

I have a severe hearing impairment.  It is very difficult to hear anything.

But instead of the expected the “a-ha” moment, the employee offers her a wheelchair. FAIL!   

I do not expect everyone to be sensitive to every disability. People are just not very good at putting themselves in someone else’s shoes.  But, when someone takes the time to explain their needs to you, take the time to listen and try to help.

Via Disability Matters.

Additional Posts

  • Tomasz,

    I hope you don't mind but I submitted your link to DeafRead.com and hopefully will bring you a few more readers with opinions and suggestions that might help you.

    :)

    Ben Vess
  • JB
    Deb should have answered "No, I don't need assistance. Thank you for asking." I do not think that Deb understood the employee.
  • What kind of assistance does Deb need? She is at the counter and is able to converse with the UA employee, as we can see they are having a conversation.

    I guess my question is what kind of assistance does Deb need? Deb never elaborated. All she said was Yes. Well, Hello! yes, what?

    From my experience, the only kind of assistance that a deaf person would need is to be kept up to date on the status of the flight and any pertinent information that a deaf person would have a "need to know" in order to be able to catch his/her flight on time. I have found it to be very frustrating that the airline employee manning the boarding desk would not be able to keep a deaf traveler up to date on any delays or other need to know information. In my case, I was told that she could not do that (keep me informed,) rather she suggested I check with her every 15 min or so. [my flight was delayed for 12 hours! imagine, every time I heard something being said on the public announcement system, I had to go and find out what the latest development is and I probably went up to her like more than 50 times that whole time] The time table screen on monitors usually do not provide these information. My experience resulted in my having to go to the boarding desk and ask what is happening every time I hear a loud PA system blaring something I do not understand. What if a person was deaf? how would the person know that there is additional information being announced? And even when I was told what was happening, by the time three planes were available for take off, the boarding attendance was crowded by lots of people, and I almost got on the wrong plane because she was not available to tell me which plane I needed to get on. It was a horrible experience and I do wish there were PA announcement that is subtitled on a screen as well.

    I'm sorry, but, I think both Failed.

    We do not need interpreters at the airport. We do not need special treatment. I wonder if Deb was expecting to be bumped into first class as is the practice with some airline if you are deaf. And I am also aware of many deaf people doing that, acting dumb, going up to the counter and announce "I am deaf." and stares at the check in desk employee with hopes that they will upgrade their ticket to 1st class for free. We definitely DO NOT need a wheelchair, unless, of course...a deaf person is also physically disabled as such that he/she would need one.

    What's the real story here with Deb, anyway?
  • Dr. Mostert comments in his original post what he feels the UA employee should have done.

    “Ok, it says here that you’re deaf. What can we do to help you? How about you stay as close to the counter as possible, and whenever there’s an announcement, either come over to me, or I’ll come to you, and tell you what we said.”

    Just FYI.
  • mishkazena
    It happens more often than the public realizes. Deaf people have reported being handed Brialle materials by some people upon hearing that they are Deaf.
  • Sounds as if the airline procedures manual might be inadequate. The training the staffers get is probably "offer all disabled people wheelchairs".

    Suggestion: give each airline a sheet for their manuals, giving idiot-proof instructions on how to handle deaf passengers.
    For example: seating near the stewardess station. Visual aids and captioning. Offer pagers with text information in case of delays or ask for pager address if the deaf passenger is carrying one. There are more ideas that others can contribute!
blog comments powered by Disqus